In the following, I will reconstruct Immanuel Kant’s supreme principle of pure reason, as formed on the procedure of reason in syllogisms. I will then address how this supreme principle goes beyond mere procedure of syllogistic inference.
The supreme principle of pure reason is introduced in the passage, “…when the conditioned is given, then so is the whole series of conditions subordinated one to the other, which is itself unconditioned, also given (i.e., contained in the object and its connection.)” (A307-8/B364).
In the Dialectic, the principle of supreme reason is situated in the sphere of reason, distinct from the understanding, and manifests as an engagement in syllogistic inference. Broadly, such an inference consists of the descending and ascending functions. In examining the structure of said functions, we will arrive at an understanding of the SPPR as based on the procedure of reason in syllogisms.
A syllogism requires a major and minor premise, from which a conclusion is derived. The major premise is a universal proposition, or, a rule through the understanding. It should be noted that the SPPR presupposes the pure concepts of the understanding, in that it operates at a level where judgements have already been supplied by the understanding to reason; reason employs the concepts of the understanding in a sphere where the world of appearances has already been constituted. While understanding belongs to the immanent, reason resides in the transcendental. Here, understanding may be understood as the faculty for ‘bringing forth’ representations, and the pure concept of the understanding is that which gives unity to the synthesis of the manifold of representations.
We then bring a cognition under the condition of the rule––this is done via judgment, which, once again, has already been provided by the understanding. This is the minor premise. The conclusion is then derived a priori, as it is via reason, using the mediating relation, the syllogism. The syllogism deals not with intuitions, but with concepts and judgments. It comes to know the objects without immediate access to intuition––the object and the syllogism is mediated by the understanding and its judgments. This is the essence of the unity of reason, which, unlike the unity of understanding, is not the unity of possible experience. Thus, we can understand how a “syllogism is nothing but a judgment mediated by the subsumption of its condition under a universal rule” (A307, B364), where the universal rule is the major premise. Further, we can now also understand what is meant by “the formal and logical procedure of reason in syllogisms” (A306,B363)––the procedure is formal because, as stated, there stands understanding and judgment through which the object is mediated, keeping reason distinct from the sphere of the immanent.
We can understand this on a concrete level with the following example:
- Major Premise: All men are mortal.
- Minor Premise: K. is a man.
- K is mortal.
Here, the middle-term of the syllogism is ‘man’.
Thus, the premise provides the condition from which the conditioned, the conclusion, may be inferred. This order of deduction constitutes the descending function of reason. In the opposite direction, there is a movement upwards, the ‘ascending’ function, in which conditions are derived from the given conditioned. These are called prosyllogisms. For reason to discover the conditions under which an object is, it requires the totality of conditions, or the unconditioned totality, which ensures that its purpose will not be stifled by a regress of conditions without end. In other words, reason must “advance towards completeness by an ascent to ever higher conditions” (A309/B365). This is the crux of the SPPR––that for any given conditioned object, one is also given the totality of the unconditioned. We can now see what is meant by “when the conditioned is given, then so is the…unconditioned, also given”.
The entirety of this process is facilitated by syllogisms, which, as previously articulated, act as the mediating connection allowing the movement from the unconditioned to the conditioned and vice versa. In this way is the SPPR based on the procedure of reason in syllogisms.
The supreme principle of pure reason develops beyond the syllogistic inference from which it’s based, and, in its ascending acquisition of the unconditioned, will eventually push us fully into the realm of illusion. Reason will be caught in the quagmire of transcendental illusion, thus necessitating further correction––a necessary blunder for the dialectic to move forward.
With the SPPR, we thus arrive at transcendental ideas, or, concepts of unconditioned totalities––under the system of transcendental ideas, since the way an object is conditioned corresponds to how it is synthesized, the transcendental ideas can be understood as ideas of complete syntheses. Reason now becomes a transcendental faculty capable of “real use” (A299/B355-6). This entails a movement away from the empirical sphere, as absolute totality cannot belong to experience. In other words, from the viewpoint of subjective deduction, transcendental ideas are necessarily provided a priori from our mode of cognition. Yet from objective deduction, we find that transcendental ideas cannot be demonstrated to have application to objects. We thus are left at an impasse, where reason has provided what kind of objects are needed in order to grasp the complete conditions for appearances, while also not enabling those objects to be actually given. As such, reason has “nothing to do with the absolute completeness from the side of the conditioned” (A336/B393). Further, the ascending series is found to be related differently to reason than the descending series. While in the perspective of the ascending, a cognition is seen as the conditioned, and so necessitates a series of complete conditions in their totality, the perspective of the descending stipulates the same cognition be a condition to which reason may be “entirely indifferent” (A332/B389), unconcerned with the possibility of a totality of prior conditions. The SPPR can thus be further clarified as a principle concerning itself with unconditioned totalities as presupposed from the vantage point of the conditioned.
The SPPR also belies another facet of reason, in that though an object is conceivable in that it can be thought of, a knowledge claim of the object––the question of its existence––is impossible. This may be seen in the aforementioned issue with objective deduction. There is now the qualification of transcendent metaphysics as moving from legitimate concepts of unconditioned totalities, to illegitimate concepts of real objects. We so stumble into transcendental illusion, where images of certain objects are applied into a realm beyond experience. It becomes the task of the Dialectic to expose this illusion that reason becomes entrapped in, correcting this aberration and so driving the dialectic forward.
In conclusion, the supreme principle of pure reason is, in its most rudimentary form, a principle by which we may understand a conditioned object to presuppose a totality of conditions––this is divined through an ascending series of syllogisms, which, via mediation, allow use to move to and from the major and minor, and the conclusion. This may be constituted in the logical maxim, that “the proper principle of reason in general…is to find the unconditioned for the conditioned” (A307/B364), which requires the SPPR in order to become a principle of pure reason in the first place. But to go beyond Kant’s account of syllogisms, we see the placement of the SPPR in the wider dialectic in terms of illusion––SPPR offers no guarantee of its objective legitimacy, opening the gateway to transcendental illusion.








Leave a Reply